Do I need a will?
Can I write my own?
Isn't estate
planning just for the wealthy? Don't I just need a will?
What is estate
planning?
Is there
anything I can do to prepare for planning my estate?
How important is
communication in Estate Planning?
What does it cost?
Do
I need a will?
Clients
quite often begin our initial conference with just that question. It is
a very legitimate question and one that I take seriously. It means not
only, "Do I have to spend this money?" but also, and just as important,
"I don't understand what this is all about."
Almost
everyone needs a will. I have been practicing law since 1971 and I have
had one person who I concluded did not need a will. She was a young
single woman with no children. Her only assets were her car, a bank
account and her employee benefits. If she died she wanted everything to
go to her mother. If she died without a will, everything would go to
her mother anyway. Her mother was on her bank account and her mother
was named the beneficiary of her employee benefits. Thus all of these
assets could be transferred to her mother without a will and without
probate. Also, her car could be transferred by signing an affidavit
provided by the motor vehicle registration department.
She
left my office without a will. She is the only client who clearly and
completely qualified.
It is
true that I have handled many estates for people who have died without
a will and their estates are resolved without great expense. However,
there is an element of luck and I have handled many more estates where
the costs were unnecessarily high because there was no will.
Finally,
I admit that I have seen some estates where the will was a mess and
everybody would have been better off if the person had died without a
will. This too is unusual and has as much to do with the lawyer who
wrote the will as anything else.
Can
I write my own?
Yes,
you can. Again, I have probated wills that were hand-written. I have
also probated wills that were forms or where someone had copied from
someone else. Some have worked just fine and some have been a disaster.
Texas
allows for holographic wills, that is, wills solely in the handwriting
of the testator. However, Texas, like all states, has several
safeguards to insure that a will is the final, freely made will of the
decedent.
The
most common problems with wills written without the assistance of an
attorney are:
Intent:
Was the document intended to be a will and what did the testator mean
when he used a particular word?
Lack
of Intent: The second set of problems arises from what was not
said. Did the testator make clear what happens if the beneficiary, or a
beneficiary, predeceases him?
Lack
of formalities: Was the will signed with the formalities required
under Texas law?
Independent
Executor without bond: Did the will specifically name a person to
act as independent executor without bond?
To
write your own will is like trying to fix your own car. You may be able
to do it, but there may be problems. And unlike with your car, if you
do not do it right, no one will know until it is too late.
Isn't
estate planning just for the wealthy? Don't I just need a will?
No
and no. While estate planning sounds sophisticated, it has a meaning
that applies to almost everyone (see below). In fact, smaller estates
are in just as much need of planning as large ones. If a person of
modest wealth does not carefully plan what happens to his property when
he dies, the results can be disastrous. All of his estate may not pass
to his spouse; or his estate may pass to his minor children and be
subject to a guardianship; or his life insurance or employee benefits
may pass differently than the beneficiaries of his will; or he may not
have made arrangements for his incapacity.
What
is estate planning?
Estate
planning is the process of thinking out the consequences and results of
growing old and dying. Generally it has 7 elements, each of which must
be carefully addressed.
- Who
are the objects of my bounty? Who do I want to receive my property
on my death?
- How
are they to receive it? Is a trust needed for my minor children? Is
a trust needed so my spouse can receive the benefits during her life
and then it passes to my children (possibly from a prior marriage) on
her death? Should my spouse have a power of appointment? Do any of my
children have special needs requiring that their share of my estate
needs to be held in trust for them (and is any special language needed
to allow them to qualify for governmental benefits)?
- Who
shall be my fiduciaries? Who will be my executor, the trustee and
if I have my children, the guardian?
- Creditors.
Do I or my beneficiaries have any creditor issues? Is it appropriate to
arrange my affairs to minimize exposure to my creditors? Do I have any
spendthrift beneficiaries? Do I have any beneficiaries who may be
subject to lawsuits, such as doctors?
- Taxes.
Is my estate subject to taxes? If so, there are many actions that can
be taken to reduce or eliminate the tax burden on my death.
- Liquidity.
Will there be a cash problem on my death -- taxes, debts or the fact
that I will not be generating any income? How can those problems be
anticipated and solved or minimized?
- Old
Age Planning. Who do I want making decisions for me if I become
unable to manage my own affairs?
Is
there anything I can do to prepare for planning my estate?
Absolutely
yes. Two things: Read and talk to people. Think about those among your
friends whose opinion you respect. Ask them. They have probably been
through the same process. Ask them about what they did, what they read
and how they prepared.
Read:
There are numerous books and frequent articles. A particularly helpful
book is How to Live and Die with Texas Probate, Charles
Saunders, Editor. The more you read, the better your questions for the
attorney.
But
don't get bogged down. There is a lot of material out there and a
lot of questions. It is very easy to do nothing because you are not
quite ready. That is a much bigger mistake. You are always going to
have questions. You will not have them all answered before you call an
attorney.
How
important is communication in Estate Planning?
Attorney. It is vital. It starts
with the attorney. The information you share with the attorney is
almost all of your most personal affairs: How much money do you have;
what is its form and nature; what about your family worries you; how is
your health; who do you want to look after you when you get old; who
should not be allowed to look after you.
You
need to be comfortable discussing these issues. If you do not feel
comfortable, change lawyers. The quality of your planning will depend
in great part on the ability of you and your attorney to translate your
concerns and wishes into a workable plan.
Fiduciaries.
You need to tell your decision makers (your fiduciaries, your
executors, trustees, power of attorney holders, etc.) who they are,
under what circumstances they are to step in and where the necessary
documents are located.
Family.
Finally, communication with your family is important. As a general rule
you want to discuss your plans with your family -- especially if you do
not treat the children equally or if you have a spouse and children by
a prior marriage.
If
your family hears from your mouth what your wishes are, it reduces
dramatically the likelihood that they will contest your will or fight
each other. If they hear the plan directly from you, then they know it
is your wish. If, however, they read about it for the first time after
your death, suspicion and mistrust can run rampant.
Exceptions.
This is a general rule. Sometimes there is a problem person. To tell
him, or her, would merely invite acrimony now, which will continue
unabated after death. This happens with some frequency and is a
legitimate reason for not disclosing your plans. If at all possible,
though, it generally makes matters easier for those left behind if it
is discussed during life. There is a natural tendency with most people
to not discuss these matters. That should be examined very carefully
before deciding to remain silent.
Sometimes
the plan may change. It can be a mistake to write a will and tell
everybody its contents only to change it. Announcing the contents can
create expectations. To disappoint those expectations can create hurt
and anger and increase the likelihood of litigation.
What
does it cost?
Unfortunately
this important question is the hardest to answer. The services can
range from a very simple will with no trusts and no tax planning to
sophisticated wills, with trusts, limited partnerships, charitable
annuities and grantor retained income trusts.
If
you look in the paper you will see wills advertised for as low as $50.
For that price you should not expect to meet the attorney or get
anything but a cookie cutter will. The amount of skill of the attorney
could also be in question.
However,
most attorneys will either discuss this issue with you over the phone
or will meet with you the first time without any charge. I usually have
a brief phone conversation to determine if we are possible matches. I
try to give some sense of the probable costs. If the fee range is
workable for the client and I think we can work together, I schedule a
first meeting. If I am not hired, I do not charge for that meeting. If
I am hired, that time is usually valuable and I charge for that meeting.
In
most instances I am able to give an estimate of cost at the first
meeting.
Cost Questionnaire
The
more of the following questions you can answer with yes,
the less your probate procedure will cost you:
- Has
the estate been planned?
- Is
the will up to date?
- Is
the will self-proving?
- Does
it name an independent executor?
- Does
it waive the requirement of bond?
- Is
the fair market value of the estate less than $650,000?
- Is
there only one beneficiary of the will?
- Are
all of the surviving children also the children of the surviving
spouse?
- Are
the bequests to the family made in the predictable and natural manner?
- Have
you eliminated or reduced all possible areas of controversy: family,
property, bequests?
- Did
the testator discuss and explain the estate plan with the family?
- Can
the debts be resolved without delay or controversy?
|